As we draw ever closer to the Ryder Cup, I don’t know about you but Im getting damn excited. Like the players getting fitted for their uniforms, I have been checking to ensure that the elastic on the pyjamas pants will allow as much beer and pizza as I can possibly put into me over a three day stint on the couch. Like Monty, I have some big decisions, and I can relate them to the golf. For instance, do I go with the full Irish fry up first thing Friday morning (does Monty lead with the Molinari brothers?) or do I ease into it with some scrambled egg on toast (McDowell & McIlroy?). It doesn’t stop there, at which point to I introduce the veterans of Zen Chinese and Dominio’s into the mix (Harrington & Westwood)? And to complicate the matter further, at lunch, do I introduce a glass of fine red wine (Jimenez), a chilled beer (Kaymer) or a drop of fiery whiskey (Poulter)……..ahhh, so many decisions and yet all to be enjoyed and debated.
One debate that will not go away though is the one that surrounds Monty’s wildcards. So much so, I have decided to weight in and comment on each individually:
Edoardo Molinari: Regardless of what happened in Gleneagles, this man deserved a wildcard selection for the Ryder Cup in my eyes. Many are saying that his win in Gelneagles was responsible for Casey getting the axe. However, as far as I am concerned, Molinari should have been pick number one. Despite making his debut in some of the majors, he made the cut in every one of them, which is no small achievement. Add to that his impressive win at the Barclays Scottish Open and it is evident he is a big game player. More importantly for me though, was his decision to play in the Italian Open back in May a opposed to the more illustrious Players Championship in Sawgrass. It is this loyalty and national pride which stood out for me. If you ever want to see how important it is for him, just look at his reaction at winning the World Cup with his brother last year. Europe needs Edoardo’s passion and desire to win, especially now that the likes of Montgomerie, Clarke and Garcia are absent.
Luke Donald: Terrific ball striker, good Ryder Cup player and a calming influence in what can be a nerve-wracking week. Although he did not admit so, I am convinced that what sealed Donalds place was his appearance at the Wales Open at Celtic Manor, at the request of Captain Monty. Don’t get me wrong, he has played some great golf this year but his selection was not as clear cut as some might believe in my view. While he wont get the crowd fired up, his demeanor and ability to take the rough with the smooth could be a valuable asset in the foursomes and singles matches.
Justin Rose: It is not often you win twice in the US and still miss out on the Ryder Cup in the same year. For Rose that is exactly what has happened and yet still, most of the golfing public expected it to be so. It’s strange because Rose has a fine record in Ryder Cup and indeed would seem like an ideal partner for Ian Poulter. So why is it that everyone tends to agree in his omission? I think it is down to his apparent lack of desire to play in the event. For some reason, it is not where his focus lies at present. Indeed, David Howell commented recently that he believes Rose is solely fixated on the Fed Ex cup this season. In an individual sport, it’s difficult to criticize the players too much for keeping to their rigid schedule but Monty was no doubt disappointed by Rose’s attitude toward the Ryder Cup over the past few months I feel
Padraig Harrington & Paul Casey: And then there were two. This is where most of the debate has revolved around. Regardless of who he picked, I would be sitting here saying one was extremely lucky and the other extremely unfortunate. First, lets deal with Casey.
His injury in 2009 meant he missed some of the initial qualifying events for the Ryder Cup and therefore he was immediately at a disadvantage. He battled gamely throughout 2010 but to no avail as he missed out on automatic qualification. Still in with a chance with two weeks to go, Casey decided the Fed Ex Cup was his priority and he has subsequently paid the price. However, when you consider Casey’s matchplay pedigree and Ryder Cup record, one could make the argument that Casey’s name should have been on the teamsheet before either Molinari, Donald, Harrington or Rose. It is a valid case and one in which I cannot deny. It is also something Monty must have struggled with. However for me, Casey’s first sin in Monty’s eyes was not playing in Celtic Manor earlier in the year at his request. The second thing was his refusal to play in any of the final two European events and the final nail in the coffin came when Molinari won in Gleneagles. Supporters of Casey will justifiably fight his corner but one has ever reason to nevertheless question Casey’s decision making and perhaps point the finger of blame at what appeared to be a cockiness about his inclusion
Harrington on the other hand can consider himself a very lucky man. He has blamed his poor scheduling for his inability to qualify but in truth it has been his poor performances, especially in the majors. Harrington keeps telling us his game is fine but in truth, it is not. I understand why he keeps saying this as the mental side of the game is vital and you must believe in yourself if you are to compete at the highest level. Indeed, Woods has for years now been in denial about his long game but finally, the rest of the world has woken up to his erratic form off the tee. When Monty sat down with his Ryder Cup vice captains, what did they exactly see in Harrington? He has not won a competitive event since 2008, he hasn’t won a single match in his last two Ryder Cup appearances and after being critical of Poulter back in 2008 for not playing the last qualifying event, Harrington too skipped the final two qualifying events in Europe. One would imagine there is little case to be made for Harrington but I strongly disagree. Although harping on past glories is never advisable, in Harrington’s case, Im making an exception. He is a not a 3-time major winner for nothing and this has to be respected, although not alone enough to earn him a place in my view. So what are we missing, why did he feature so highly in the plans of Monty, Clarke, McGinley and Bjorn. Well, for one, Harrington too has had had injury issues like Casey. He agreed to Monty’s request to play in Celtic Manor earlier in the year only to be forced out with required knee surgery. This was undoubtedly browning point number one. He has also had a busy year playing exhibition matches against Rory McIlroy and I wonder if Monty sees a potential fourball partnership there in the event that the McIlroy & McDowell pair might not perform as well as we expect them to do. Then there is Harrington’s attitude towards the game. His ability to take the rough with the smooth and simply move on is something one cannot deny and it is something which will be invaluable to any rookie Harrington plays alongside. While I expect it might be Kaymer in the fourballs, I don’t think Monty would hesitate in putting him with Hanson and still expect a big performance from the pair. While Padraig’s driving is erratic and he certainly mixes a lot of bogeys with birdies, this should not be an issue at all in the fourballs and such is the strength in depth this year, he won’t be played in the foursome’s anyway. Indeed, I would only expect the likes of Poulter, Kaymer and McIlroy to play all five matches (perhaps one of the Molinari brothers too) so Harrington’s omission from the foursomes is not a problem. Where he really needs to deliver for Monty is in the singles though. Such is the faith Monty is showing, it would not surprise me to see him keep Harrington toward the tail end of the field and expect him to deliver when required. Whether he can or not will be fascinating.
I personally will be keeping my fingers and toes crossed such is my admiration for the man, but should we be looking back on another poor Ryder Cup for Harrington, the knives will be out and it will be difficult to justify his selection over Paul Casey. Until then, it’s time to put the debate to rest and get behind the European team. This Ryder Cup is certainly building up to be a cracker!
Recent Comments